Friday, August 07, 2009

Note to APA: Progressive Clergy Can Help Your Clients

On Wednesday night, the American Psychological Association released a new statement that therapy to help gay people become straight (known as reparative therapy by some) doesn't work. I'm going to reprint the whole press release below.

It confirms more than 40 years of studies that clearly demonstrate that such therapy is ineffective, that sexual orientation cannot be changed by therapy, and is particularly ineffective with people who have known they are gay or lesbian from an early age. It reinforces earlier APA statements, and should put to rest claims for change.

It also advises psychologists who work with clients whose religious beliefs conflict with their being gay or lesbian:

"explore possible life paths that address the reality of their sexual orientation, reduce the stigma associated with homosexuality, respect the client's religious beliefs, and consider possibilities for a religiously and spiritually meaningful and rewarding life.""In other words," Glassgold said, "we recommend that psychologists be completely honest about the likelihood of sexual orientation change, and that they help clients explore their assumptions and goals with respect to both religion and sexuality."

The full report is not yet available, but I do hope that it advises psychologists to refer such clients to religious leaders who affirm sexual and gender diversity as part of God's blessings, who can help them explore alternative understandings of seemingly homophobic sacred texts, and to understand that there are religious communities where they would be fully welcome and included. I work with people struggling with these issues all the time, and it often takes only a few sessions with a clergy person for people to feel affirmed and welcome. There have been many times where simply telling someone that I know that God loves them just the way they are...and that there are many denominations and religious leaders who feel that way...helps them reach self-acceptance.

No one should ever have to choose between their sexuality and their religion -- or vice versa. I hope the final APA report says that as well.

Here's the press release.




TORONTO—The American Psychological Association adopted a resolution Wednesday stating that mental health professionals should avoid telling clients that they can change their sexual orientation through therapy or other treatments.

The "Resolution on Appropriate Affirmative Responses to Sexual Orientation Distress and Change Efforts" also advises that parents, guardians, young people and their families avoid sexual orientation treatments that portray homosexuality as a mental illness or developmental disorder and instead seek psychotherapy, social support and educational services "that provide accurate information on sexual orientation and sexuality, increase family and school support and reduce rejection of sexual minority youth."

The approval, by APA's governing Council of Representatives, came at APA's annual convention, during which a task force presented a report that in part examined the efficacy of so-called "reparative therapy," or sexual orientation change efforts (SOCE).

"Contrary to claims of sexual orientation change advocates and practitioners, there is insufficient evidence to support the use of psychological interventions to change sexual orientation," said Judith M. Glassgold, PsyD, chair of the task force. "Scientifically rigorous older studies in this area found that sexual orientation was unlikely to change due to efforts designed for this purpose. Contrary to the claims of SOCE practitioners and advocates, recent research studies do not provide evidence of sexual orientation change as the research methods are inadequate to determine the effectiveness of these interventions." Glassgold added: "At most, certain studies suggested that some individuals learned how to ignore or not act on their homosexual attractions. Yet, these studies did not indicate for whom this was possible, how long it lasted or its long-term mental health effects. Also, this result was much less likely to be true for people who started out only attracted to people of the same sex."

Based on this review, the task force recommended that mental health professionals avoid misrepresenting the efficacy of sexual orientation change efforts when providing assistance to people distressed about their own or others' sexual orientation.

APA appointed the six-member Task Force on Appropriate Therapeutic Responses to Sexual Orientation in 2007 to review and update APA's 1997 resolution, "Appropriate Therapeutic Responses to Sexual Orientation," and to generate a report. APA was concerned about ongoing efforts to promote the notion that sexual orientation can be changed through psychotherapy or approaches that mischaracterize homosexuality as a mental disorder.

The task force examined the peer-reviewed journal articles in English from 1960 to 2007, which included 83 studies. Most of the studies were conducted before 1978, and only a few had been conducted in the last 10 years. The group also reviewed the recent literature on the psychology of sexual orientation.

"Unfortunately, much of the research in the area of sexual orientation change contains serious design flaws," Glassgold said. "Few studies could be considered methodologically sound and none systematically evaluated potential harms."

As to the issue of possible harm, the task force was unable to reach any conclusion regarding the efficacy or safety of any of the recent studies of SOCE: "There are no methodologically sound studies of recent SOCE that would enable the task force to make a definitive statement about whether or not recent SOCE is safe or harmful and for whom," according to the report.
"Without such information, psychologists cannot predict the impact of these treatments and need to be very cautious, given that some qualitative research suggests the potential for harm," Glassgold said. "Practitioners can assist clients through therapies that do not attempt to change sexual orientation, but rather involve acceptance, support and identity exploration and development without imposing a specific identity outcome."


As part of its report, the task force identified that some clients seeking to change their sexual orientation may be in distress because of a conflict between their sexual orientation and religious beliefs. The task force recommended that licensed mental health care providers treating such clients help them "explore possible life paths that address the reality of their sexual orientation, reduce the stigma associated with homosexuality, respect the client's religious beliefs, and consider possibilities for a religiously and spiritually meaningful and rewarding life."
"In other words," Glassgold said, "we recommend that psychologists be completely honest about the likelihood of sexual orientation change, and that they help clients explore their assumptions and goals with respect to both religion and sexuality."

3 comments:

Desmond Ravenstone said...

I'd generally agree with you, being a fellow UU, but there is one point to consider. Religious progressives are often portrayed as either distorting or dismissing the Bible, and of being "too worldly" in our perspective.

Progressive clergy need to be able to respond to the "Bible-based" rhetoric of anti-gay churches, and in a way which presents our overall spirituality.

It's the difference between taking selected verses literally, and taking the entire Bible seriously.

Jake Erickson said...

cheers. here's a link to the report itself:
http://www.apa.org/pi/lgbc/publications/therapeutic-response.pdf

Steve Caldwell said...

Debra,

I would recommend checking out a book by a sociology professor in our community called Be Not Deceived: The Sacred and Sexual Struggles of Gay and Ex-Gay Christian Men by Michelle Wolkomir.

http://www.amazon.com/Be-Not-Deceived-Struggles-Christian/dp/081353822X

Her book is based on sociology field work that she did comparing and contrasting the Metropolitan Community Church's (MCC) approach to homosexuality with the ex-gay movement's approach to homosexuality.

Gay men and lesbians from conservative Evangelical Christian backgrounds do have a dilemma. Most conservative Christians have been told that the Bible says homosexuality is a sin that will lead one straight to hell.

For a person who has realized that he or she is gay and conservative Christian, this presents a problem for these individuals.

Both the MCC and ex-gay folks start with a Bible-based worldview that takes hell very seriously but they end up in different places regarding homosexuality and the Bible.